Courts and medication assisted treatment: Your legal rights

Have you been kicked off medication assisted treatment by a court? Here’s how you can fight for your legal rights.

4
minute read
Reviewed by: Dr. Juan Goecke, M.D.
Reviewed by: Dr. Juan Goecke, M.D.

ARTICLE OVERVIEW: The evidence of Medication assisted treatment for opioid addiction effectiveness in decreasing illicit drug use, overdose, infectious disease transmission, and crime is overwhelming. Despite this, some people are forced off their treatment for various reasons. If you want to know what to do in these scenarios, keep reading we review this here.

TABLE OF CONTENTS:


By Sally Friedman, Legal Director of the Legal Action Center

Why This Happens?

The evidence is overwhelming: Medication assisted treatment (“MAT” for short) for opioid addiction is highly effective in decreasing illicit drug use, overdose, infectious disease transmission, and crime. MAT – the use of medications, such as methadone, buprenorphine-naloxone (Suboxone), and injectable naltrexone (Vivitrol), in combination with counseling and behavioral therapies – provides a whole-patient approach to treatment.

Despite the overwhelming evidence of MAT’s effectiveness, courts and other criminal justice and child welfare agencies often force people off their MAT medication. Typical reasons people are forced off MAT include:

Ready for help?
Call us today. You don’t need to face addiction on your own.
1-888-882-1456
  • Concern about illicit sale of MAT medications.
  • The mistaken belief that MAT is “substituting one addiction for another.”
  • The mistaken belief that people in MAT are not truly in recovery.

What can you do if this Catch 22 happens to you? Get off medications and risk relapse? Stay on the medications and likely face incarceration or the lost custody of your children?

Learn how to advocate

The first thing you should do is advocate. Orders to “taper off” MAT medications often result from a lack of understanding about the nature of opioid addiction. In addition, judges and others generally do not realize that policies prohibiting MAT can violate anti-discrimination laws. Education can make a difference. Below are suggestions for how to advocate to stay on life-saving MAT.*

Tip #1: Get A Lawyer Who Will Fight For You To Stay On MAT.  Then, Educate Your Lawyer.

Having a lawyer who can effectively advocate for you to stay on MAT is critical. But do not assume your lawyer will be educated about MAT. Many lawyers share the same negative attitudes about MAT as the court or other agencies that order people off. Give your attorney a copy of “Advocating for Your Recovery: What to Do When Forced off Addiction Medication,” which you can find on the Legal Action Center’s MAT resource page by clicking on “publications.” This guide has detailed advocacy suggestions and resources your lawyer will need.

Also suggest that your attorney call the Legal Action Center at (212) 243-1313 for advice about challenging a requirement to stop MAT. Depending on where you live, the Legal Action Center may be able to help you. You can learn more about LAC’s legal services in this area here.

Don’t let your loved one suffer.
Addiction responds to treatment. Call us to get started.
1-888-882-1456

Tip #2: Educate The Court Or Agency Forcing You Off MAT.

Give educational materials to whomever is denying your rights. Great resources, including sample letter that you (or your advocate) can send to whomever is requiring you to get off MAT, are available in “Advocating for Your Recovery.” The sample letter explains why MAT is effective and why forcing you off can violate anti-discrimination laws.

Tip #3: Get Help From Your Prescribing/Treating Doctor And Counselor.

Treatment professionals often want to help their patients fight to stay on MAT. Here are some ways that your medical doctor or psychologist can help.

Questions about rehab?
Get confidential help day or night.
  • Access to top treatment centers
  • Compassionate guidance
  • Financial assistance options
  • Ask your treatment providers to write a letter. If you have a prescribing doctor and counselor, get letters from both. It is very important that the letters be detailed and address the concerns of whomever is forcing you off MAT. Give your provider the list of suggested topics to include in a letter, which you will find in “Advocating for Your Recovery.”
  • Ask your doctor to testify in court.
  • Follow up with phone calls, where appropriate.

Tip #4: Reach Out To Others Who May Be Able To Advocate For You.

Here are some people you can ask for help:

More questions about advocacy and medication assisted treatment?

Do you still have questions about advocacy issues and MAT? Please leave your questions in the comments section below. Please leave us a message. We will do our best to reply to you personally and promptly!

Start your
recovery today.
Reference Sources:
LAC: Legality of Denying Access to Medication Assisted Treatment in the Criminal Justice System
ADA: How to File an Americans with Disabilities Act Complaint with the U.S. Department of Justice
About the author: Sally Friedman is the Legal Director of the Legal Action Center, a non-profit law and policy organization that fights discrimination against people with criminal justice histories, substance use disorders, and HIV/AIDS. Ms. Friedman has successfully litigated cases challenging such discrimination, including winning Innovative Health Systems v. City of White Plains, the landmark case establishing that the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) prohibits cities from using their zoning laws to exclude programs serving individuals with disabilities. In 2011, Ms. Friedman authored the report, “Legality of Denying Access to Medication Assisted Treatment in the Criminal Justice System.” Prior to joining the Legal Action Center, Ms. Friedman worked as a litigation associate at the New York law firm of Kramer, Levin, Naftalis, Nessen, Kamin and Frankel. She is a graduate of New York University School of Law and Brown University.
* The suggestions in this article are legal information, not legal advice. For legal advice, please speak to a lawyer.
About the author
Lee Weber is a published author, medical writer, and woman in long-term recovery from addiction. Her latest book, The Definitive Guide to Addiction Interventions is set to reach university bookstores in early 2019.
Medical Reviewers
Dr. Goecke is a medical doctor and general surgeon with personal experience of...

All of the information on this page has been reviewed and verified by a licensed medical professional.

34 Comments

Leave a Reply to Amanda Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I have read and agree to the conditions outlined in the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

  1. I did everything the court wanted too with DCS and DCS voted for me full custody but judge said I could only have unsupervised and couldn’t get full custody until I came off my subutex medication Is this legal?

    1. Hi Nicole. All the decisions the court makes must be legal. However, if you still have some doubts please consult with an attorney.

  2. Do I have the right to refuse the vivatrol program if I am on probation. They threating me all the time about if I don’t take the vivatrol program I will get violated. But the sad part is I am not on drugs. I failed for suboxne one time which was 9 months ago. My drug screens have been negative every time. Can some tell me if I can file something with the courts for them to stop trying to violate my rights

  3. I’m on misdemeanor probation, since October. For years I’ve been going to a cash clinic and getting a prescription for Suboxone. When I signed up for probation they said I would have to transition to vivitrol but the issue wasn’t pressed. I caught a new charge and when I went to court, I failed a drug screen for alcohol. My PO locked me up for 26 days. He basically told me it was to force me off the sub. On day 26 I was brought to court and bonded out. He sent me to the Vivitrol doc that day and I received a script for the pill form of Vivitrol. It made me so sick I wanted to die so I stopped taking it and tried all day Friday to get ahold of my PO but the phones were messed up. I found out about a doctor that accepts insurance and prescribes Suboxone, that other people with the same PO as me are going to, and the PO is ok with it. So I went to see my PO this morning. He made me drop urine before he would talk to me. So I told him, this vivitrol pill made me sick, I can’t get the shot and feel like that all month. I found out about this place called Self Refined, and he cut me off right then and said NO. He said the Vivitrol doc is the only doc he refers to. He also said I probably used Suboxone and that’s why I got sick, even though I passed my drug test for it. When I asked why some people can go get Suboxone from this clinic, he said fair is a place to ride rides and eat cotton candy . He told me if I needed Suboxone I could get it from the Vivitrol doc. but So I went there. The doc was busy but the nurse told me the only way I’ll get Suboxone from there is if I fail a drug test, which would just get me locked back up. Him saying he only referred to one doctor and refusing to let me go anywhere else, even someone that accepts my insurance, makes me think money is changing hands but can he do that? Can he lock me up if I go to another doctor? As long as it’s not a cash clinic anyway.

    1. Hi Lynn. I suggest that you consult with your PO about your problems with your doctor and your current clinic. We don’t see that there will be any problem if you change you change your doctor, but you need to ask your PO about any changes.

  4. Please help. This is happening to us. Can you reccommend some lawyers in AL that will fight for us. Court appointed here are in with the judges. They said we would lose custody if we didn’t go to rehab for Suboxone which is absolutely ridiculous.

  5. I’m currently on drug court.

    I was only able to stay on suboxone because I was pregnant and ordered by a doctor to stay on it.

    Almost 2 years later, the court is messing with me and refuses to graduate me from drug court because I’m on suboxone

    They want me to get on other meds, anxiety, depression , etc. I didn’t have any of those problems until lowering my dose.

    My life has gotten 100% better. Bought a home, started my own business.

    Drug court is very bitter.

    Anyone deal with this?
    I don’t think I should get off. Been on it for 10+ years. Doctor says it’s a life sustaining med

  6. I am currently taking suboxone it had given me my life back I am going through court with my children Judge Gregory Williams in walker co alabama (jasper) has ordered me to stop taking it or lose my kids since taking suboxone. He says everybody knows it just a substitute..i dont feel that way dont believe he really understandsi have kept the same job for almost 2 yrs lived in same house and. Not taking the opiates and withdrawing…like it gave my life back.I need some help with this i want my kids and the suboxone working for me what can i do

  7. I live in alabama…i am on suboxone and going through custody court suboxone has giving me my life back…had the same job,kept my home since been taking it now Judge Williams in walker co telling me to stop taking it that it is just a substiute for drugs or not get my kids back…I do not wanna lose my children…but the suboxone working for me afraid i will go back to drugs without it what can i do to keep subs and kids please need help.

  8. My son had been going to a Methadone clinic here in Texas for the past 6 months & has had no issues until today. His counselor informed him that unless he signs A Release of Information for his med records & allow them to speak with his family Dr., that he will be terminated as a patient IMMEDIATELY.
    He has never violated the rules of the program & has always informed them of any
    & all prescription medications he takes & or that’ve been prescribed. My son doesn’t want to sign the release form due to privacy issues, wanting to keep his addiction issues private.
    Hes not trying to hide anything, he has even offered to get his his med records for them on his own, he just doesn’t feel comfortable having his Dr’s office know he’s a recovering addict… He’s terrified of the withdrawals that he’s going to go through from being cut off of Methadone without getting tapered down or worse that he’ll relapse & start using again.
    Isn’t this Illegal? Doesn’t this Violate the privacy protection of CFR 42 part 2?
    Is there anything we can do?
    Thank you for any help you can offer!

  9. I have a question. I live in TN. I failed a drug test for my probation officer for xanax. I was going to the methadone clinic and he gave me a choice to go to rehab for a month or violate me and do my 3 yr sentence in prison. My question is can I go back to the clinic without my p.o. violating me???

  10. I have client’s who have been in MAT treatment for the past 18 months, they have gone from homeless drug addicts to full time employed clean tox screen success stories except their DCFS appointed case managers bias against methadone and low SEC who recently changed their case goal to not return home due to the parents MAT involvement. The dcfs advocate and life coach have been testified in court that there is no reason for the children not to return home but the judge also believes methadone is trading one substance for another. They have been encouraged to get a lawyer but cannot afford one. Any information would be much appreciated!!

  11. Ive been disabled since 1999. Im under doctors pain management but a youth court judge has said Ive neglected my children by taking the medicine Im prescribed. I have on record an have never failed a drug test in my life. Yet Im being treated like Im some kind of drug addict because I’ve been prescribed an taken the medicine for all these years. The judge wants me to go to a drug rehab an stop taking my medicine. This is with out talking to a doctor an looking in to my medical condition. Are there any laws or any thing that can help me. Before this judge takes my childern away an gives them to someone else. Im a single father my wife died 10 years ago an I have two 11 year olds an one 13 . Please help

  12. Im disgusted at the ignorance with the WV CHILD PROTECTIVE SERVICES. I have a friend in treatment on methadone in a treatment center in WV. Theyre telling her she must detox out before getting her daughter back? This is an outrageous demand as shes in treatment for a reason. Common sense might clue these morons into the fact that its almost certain she will relapse as shes not ready!!! This enrages me! Whats wrong with these people? How can someone under professional physicians care be ordered to stop treatment or lose they’re child forever? Seems to me this is pardon my french but, ASS BACKWARDS.
    What can she do to fight this for her and for other addicts having they’re children HELD HOSTAGE. A little education about opioid addiction couldnt hurt…especially for a state with one of the highest addiction rates per capita of any others in America.

  13. I have a friend (really!) who was on probation for a drug charge, has stage 2 emphysema, asthma, bronchitis, COPD. She had a flareup, only inhaler she had was the Combivent Respamat, no rescue inhaler was available. (It had run out and although she had a script for Proair, she did not have the money to fill it) She used the Combivent, reported to her probation officer, gave her a copy of the script, the probation officer did a drug test, and she was positive for methamphetamine. ALL the current bronchial inhalers are ephedrine based, but it is l-methamphetamine in them, not d-methamphetamine. She tried explaining this to the judge, he violated her, put her on house arrest, and in the order says she can have nothing with methamphetamine in it So, with the pollen way up (we are in Florida/early spring) she is having trouble breathing, my question is, can a judge deny a person life saving treatment. Can the judge over rule what a physician feels is necessary for his patient??.

  14. Individual who was wrongfully terminated due to a HIPPA violation that was reported. Now treatment for inflammatory disease is being discontinued after a decade. Patient is now jobless and very I’ll due to human rights being stripped. Pt. will pass if no intervention soon.

  15. I desperately need help finding a lawyer pro bono or reduced rates, I have no income but was denied WV Legal Aid because of my parents income which makes no sense, and I am also a veteran. The judge suspended visitation with my daughter because I am in a legal suboxone program and long story short will not let me see my 11 year old daughter until I am forced off of it. It’s already been almost a year I haven’t seen or been able to even talk to her and go back to court in December. If I cant get help from an attorney I have no chance in getting my visitation back. Please help me.

  16. Hi I am trying to get custody of my daughter back from the state. I’m currently on methadone and the state will not give me more visits n my worker says she will take my daughter from me in court. She doesn’t see it as recovery and is always putting me down. I don’t want to relapse I almost have six months clean and I really want my daughter. Pls help thank u I live in California too.

  17. I was recently accepted into a Nursing Program, but once they found out that I am taking suboxone (from a dr. along with counseling), they dismissed me from the program, for that reason alone. Now, they are saying I absolutely have to come off my medicine before entering the program. I live in WV. I would appreciate any information you could give me. Thank you!

    1. Hi Jesse. I suggest that you consult with your doctor and a lawyer about your rights. Maybe that Nursing Program has different policy regarding suboxone. Also, you may consider finding new program.

  18. If you expect anyone but someone trying to justify it to believe that Suboxone is the same thing as true recovery…good luck. There may br more invol, it may not be as strong, it may “prevent” use of illicit opioids but it’s still an opioid which means it still changes the way you feel chemically. My child’s father admits it keeps him feeling even keeled. That’s not true sobriety and as someone who’s been clean and sober for a decade doing the hard work and learning to sit with the way I feel instead of dumping chemicals into my body…it’s an insult to call those ppl 100% sober. What makes them so special they deserve chemical assistance to get thru life and not Rob ppl? Ppl like you only help ppl like my ex continue to inflict extreme psychological damage on children all in the name of addicts deserve their children too. Yeah maybe if they’re actually good parents who actually do something hard beyond micromanaging the mother in the name of good coparenting every time they show back up demanding their rights nd calling themselves exceptional parents and hero’s for coming back again and again. The courts protect abusers, addicts and the mentally ill in custody disputes. Not children. Look at the actual statistics about children growing up with these ppl. Do you know there’s nothing preventing a parent with narcissism or sociopathy from having custody of their children. Those ppl are usually drug addicts. Often because of their issues even taking the custody away from the healthy parent. I know addiction is a disease. Serial killers have a disease too. We are our actions. Period. Stop protecting those who make bad choices and protect their victims from court systems who praise a penis who wants contact with his kids regardless of who he is or why he actually wants it. All you do is create more sick adults. Bravo for your amazing advocacy.

    1. Hi Tony. I suggest you try a search on Google using these key words: site:.gov find a lawyer in [STATE].

    1. Hello Chris. Different mental health facilities have different protocols and rules. I don’t know if she’ll monitor you or not.

  19. If anyone can help me through a custody issue while I’m on suboxone, I really need your help! I had my visitation “abated” because I was in fentanyl last summer, even though I had already begged my Dr to take me off and he did. Just happened to be a few days before I got the court letter, so looks even better for me. Even though I haven’t been on narcotics since March, I am currently now on suboxone ( two weeks today) and I KNOW that my daughters father and lawyer will make a big deal out of this and deny me seeing my daughter. I have not seen her since last August because of this btw, and NO, no one gave me a chance to defend myself last August, he just too the judge some BS and he immediately took away my rights. Even tho no one ever spoke to me nor did her father have ANY proof that I was doing anything wrong! He lied and told the judge I found out later, that I was asking the fentanyl patches , when in reality, I was already off of them before he told the judge. They want me to come to court and do a drug test, which is fine, I have one every month at my pain Dr visits, so my insurance will cover the subs. BUT, I do not want him knowing I’m on subs, so how do I go about taking a court ordered drug test, without him knowing I’m in subs? I’m pretty sure they will do the 13 panel test, which will show subs. It’s not his business and I’m fully capable of taking care of myself and my daughter ! Help!

  20. I am interested in being an advocate of those that have issues with addiction and need MAT in order to withdraw from the drugs without going “cold turkey”.

I am ready to call
i Who Answers?